docs: document P3 URL taxonomy, slug immutability, tenant invariant

Locks the new conventions into rule files so future agents and humans
don't drift back into old patterns.

- .claude/rules/app-classes.md: replaces the flat endpoint catalog
  with a taxonomy-aware reorganization (env-scoped / env-admin /
  agent-only / ingestion / cross-env discovery / admin / other).
  Adds the flat-endpoint allow-list with rationale per prefix and
  documents the tenant-filter invariant for ClickHouse queries.
- CLAUDE.md: adds four convention bullets in Key Conventions —
  URL taxonomy with allow-list pointer, slug immutability rule,
  app uniqueness as (env, app_slug), env-required on env-scoped
  endpoints.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
hsiegeln
2026-04-16 23:50:38 +02:00
parent 873e1d3df7
commit 51d7bda5b8
2 changed files with 91 additions and 38 deletions

View File

@@ -7,44 +7,94 @@ paths:
`cameleer-server-app/src/main/java/com/cameleer/server/app/`
## URL taxonomy
User-facing data and config endpoints live under `/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}/...`. Env is a path segment, never a query param. The `envSlug` is resolved to an `Environment` bean via the `@EnvPath` argument resolver (`web/EnvironmentPathResolver.java`) — 404 on unknown slug.
**Slugs are immutable after creation** for both environments and apps. Slug regex: `^[a-z0-9][a-z0-9-]{0,63}$`. Validated in `EnvironmentService.create` and `AppService.createApp`. Update endpoints (`PUT`) do not accept a slug field; Jackson drops it as an unknown property.
### Flat-endpoint allow-list
These paths intentionally stay flat (no `/environments/{envSlug}` prefix). Every new endpoint should be env-scoped unless it appears here and the reason is documented.
| Path prefix | Why flat |
|---|---|
| `/api/v1/data/**` | Agent ingestion. JWT `env` claim is authoritative; URL-embedded env would invite spoofing. |
| `/api/v1/agents/register`, `/refresh`, `/{id}/heartbeat`, `/{id}/events` (SSE), `/{id}/deregister`, `/{id}/commands`, `/{id}/commands/{id}/ack`, `/{id}/replay` | Agent self-service; JWT-bound. |
| `/api/v1/agents/commands`, `/api/v1/agents/groups/{group}/commands` | Operator fan-out; target scope is explicit in query params. |
| `/api/v1/agents/config` | Agent-authoritative config read; JWT → registry → (app, env). |
| `/api/v1/admin/{users,roles,groups,oidc,license,audit,rbac/stats,claim-mappings,thresholds,sensitive-keys,usage,clickhouse,database,environments}` | Truly cross-env admin. Env CRUD URLs use `{envSlug}`, not UUID. |
| `/api/v1/catalog`, `/api/v1/catalog/{applicationId}` | Cross-env discovery is the purpose. Env is an optional filter via `?environment=`. |
| `/api/v1/executions/{execId}`, `/processors/**` | Exchange IDs are globally unique; permalinks. |
| `/api/v1/diagrams/{contentHash}/render`, `POST /api/v1/diagrams/render` | Content-addressed or stateless. |
| `/api/v1/auth/**` | Pre-auth; no env context exists. |
| `/api/v1/health`, `/prometheus`, `/api-docs/**`, `/swagger-ui/**` | Server metadata. |
## Tenant isolation invariant
ClickHouse is shared across tenants. Every ClickHouse query must filter by `tenant_id` (from `CAMELEER_SERVER_TENANT_ID` env var, resolved via `TenantContext`/config) in addition to `environment`. New controllers added under `/environments/{envSlug}/...` must preserve this — the env filter from the path does not replace the tenant filter.
## controller/ — REST endpoints
- `AgentRegistrationController` — POST /register (requires `environmentId` in body; 400 if missing/blank), POST /heartbeat (env from body `environmentId` → JWT `env` claim; 400 if neither present during auto-heal), GET / (list), POST /refresh-token (rejects tokens with no `env` claim)
- `AgentSseController` — GET /sse (Server-Sent Events connection)
- `AgentCommandController`POST /broadcast, POST /{agentId}, POST /{agentId}/ack
- `AppController`CRUD /api/v1/apps, POST /{appId}/upload-jar, GET /{appId}/versions
- `DeploymentController` — GET/POST /api/v1/apps/{appId}/deployments, POST /{id}/stop, POST /{id}/promote, GET /{id}/logs
- `EnvironmentAdminController`CRUD /api/v1/admin/environments, PUT /{id}/jar-retention
- `ExecutionController`GET /api/v1/executions (search + detail)
- `SearchController`POST /api/v1/search, GET /routes, GET /top-errors, GET /punchcard
- `LogQueryController` — GET /api/v1/logs (filters: source, application, agentId, exchangeId, level, logger, q, environment, time range)
- `LogIngestionController`POST /api/v1/data/logs (accepts `List<LogEntry>` JSON array, each entry has `source`: app/agent). Logs WARN for: missing agent identity, unregistered agents, empty payloads, buffer-full drops, deserialization failures. Normal acceptance at DEBUG.
- `CatalogController` — GET /api/v1/catalog (unified app catalog merging PG managed apps + in-memory agents + CH stats), DELETE /api/v1/catalog/{applicationId} (ADMIN: dismiss app, purge all CH data + PG record). Auto-filters discovered apps older than `discoveryttldays` with no live agents.
- `ChunkIngestionController`POST /api/v1/ingestion/chunk/{executions|metrics|diagrams}
- `UserAdminController`CRUD /api/v1/admin/users, POST /{id}/roles, POST /{id}/set-password
- `RoleAdminController`CRUD /api/v1/admin/roles
- `GroupAdminController` — CRUD /api/v1/admin/groups
- `OidcConfigAdminController` — GET/POST /api/v1/admin/oidc, POST /test
- `SensitiveKeysAdminController` — GET/PUT /api/v1/admin/sensitive-keys. GET returns 200 with config or 204 if not configured. PUT accepts `{ keys: [...] }` with optional `?pushToAgents=true`. The fan-out iterates over every distinct `(application, environment)` slice (from persisted `application_config` rows plus currently-registered agents) and pushes per-slice merged keys — intentional global baseline + per-env overrides. Stored in `server_config` table (key `sensitive_keys`).
- `AuditLogController`GET /api/v1/admin/audit
- `MetricsController` — GET /api/v1/metrics, GET /timeseries
- `DiagramController` — GET /api/v1/diagrams/{id}, POST /api/v1/data/diagrams. Ingestion resolves applicationId + environment from the agent registry (keyed on JWT subject) and stamps both on the stored `TaggedDiagram`. `route_diagrams` CH table has an `environment` column; queries like `findProcessorRouteMapping(app, env)` filter by it.
- `DiagramRenderController` — POST /api/v1/diagrams/render (ELK layout)
- `ClaimMappingAdminController` — CRUD /api/v1/admin/claim-mappings, POST /test (accepts inline rules + claims for preview without saving)
- `LicenseAdminController` — GET/POST /api/v1/admin/license
- `AgentEventsController`GET /api/v1/agent-events (agent state change history)
- `AgentMetricsController` — GET /api/v1/agent-metrics (JVM/Camel metrics per agent instance)
- `AppSettingsController` — GET/PUT /api/v1/admin/app-settings (list), /api/v1/admin/app-settings/{appId} (per-app). All endpoints require `?environment=`.
- `ApplicationConfigController``/api/v1/config` (agent/admin observability config: traced processors, taps, route recording, per-app sensitive keys). GET list requires `?environment=`. GET/PUT/DELETE for a single app are env-scoped: for AGENT role the env comes from the JWT `env` claim (query param ignored, agents cannot spoof env); for non-agent callers env must be supplied via `?environment=` (user JWTs carry a placeholder env="default" that is NOT authoritative). `defaultConfig(application, environment)` is returned when no row exists.
- `ClickHouseAdminController` — GET /api/v1/admin/clickhouse (ClickHouse admin, conditional on infrastructure endpoints)
- `DatabaseAdminController`GET /api/v1/admin/database (PG admin, conditional on infrastructure endpoints)
- `DetailController`GET /api/v1/detail (execution detail with processor tree)
- `EventIngestionController` — POST /api/v1/data/events (agent event ingestion)
- `RbacStatsController`GET /api/v1/admin/rbac/stats
- `RouteCatalogController`GET /api/v1/routes/catalog (merged route catalog from registry + ClickHouse)
- `RouteMetricsController`GET /api/v1/route-metrics (per-route Camel metrics)
- `ThresholdAdminController` — CRUD /api/v1/admin/thresholds
- `UsageAnalyticsController` — GET /api/v1/admin/usage (ClickHouse usage_events)
### Env-scoped (user-facing data & config)
- `AppController``/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}/apps`. GET list / POST create / GET `{appSlug}` / DELETE `{appSlug}` / GET `{appSlug}/versions` / POST `{appSlug}/versions` (JAR upload) / PUT `{appSlug}/container-config`. App slug uniqueness is per-env (`(env, app_slug)` is the natural key). `CreateAppRequest` body has no env (path), validates slug regex.
- `DeploymentController``/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}/apps/{appSlug}/deployments`. GET list / POST create (body `{ appVersionId }`) / POST `{id}/stop` / POST `{id}/promote` (body `{ targetEnvironment: slug }` — target app slug must exist in target env) / GET `{id}/logs`.
- `ApplicationConfigController``/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}`. GET `/config` (list), GET/PUT `/apps/{appSlug}/config`, GET `/apps/{appSlug}/processor-routes`, POST `/apps/{appSlug}/config/test-expression`. PUT also pushes `CONFIG_UPDATE` to LIVE agents in this env.
- `AppSettingsController``/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}`. GET `/app-settings` (list), GET/PUT/DELETE `/apps/{appSlug}/settings`. ADMIN/OPERATOR only.
- `SearchController``/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}`. GET `/executions`, POST `/executions/search`, GET `/stats`, `/stats/timeseries`, `/stats/timeseries/by-app`, `/stats/timeseries/by-route`, `/stats/punchcard`, `/attributes/keys`, `/errors/top`.
- `LogQueryController`GET `/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}/logs` (filters: source, application, agentId, exchangeId, level, logger, q, time range).
- `RouteCatalogController` — GET `/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}/routes` (merged route catalog from registry + ClickHouse; env filter unconditional).
- `RouteMetricsController`GET `/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}/routes/metrics`, GET `/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}/routes/metrics/processors`.
- `AgentListController` — GET `/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}/agents` (registered agents with runtime metrics, filtered to env).
- `AgentEventsController`GET `/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}/agents/events` (lifecycle events).
- `AgentMetricsController`GET `/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}/agents/{agentId}/metrics` (JVM/Camel metrics). Rejects cross-env agents (404) as defence-in-depth.
- `DiagramRenderController`GET `/api/v1/environments/{envSlug}/apps/{appSlug}/routes/{routeId}/diagram` (env-scoped lookup). Also GET `/api/v1/diagrams/{contentHash}/render` (flat — content hashes are globally unique).
### Env admin (env-slug-parameterized, not env-scoped data)
- `EnvironmentAdminController``/api/v1/admin/environments`. GET list / POST create / GET `{envSlug}` / PUT `{envSlug}` / DELETE `{envSlug}` / PUT `{envSlug}/default-container-config` / PUT `{envSlug}/jar-retention`. Slug immutable — PUT body has no slug field; any slug supplied is dropped by Jackson. Slug validated on POST.
### Agent-only (JWT-authoritative, intentionally flat)
- `AgentRegistrationController` — POST `/register` (requires `environmentId` in body; 400 if missing), POST `/{id}/refresh` (rejects tokens with no `env` claim), POST `/{id}/heartbeat` (env from body preferred, JWT fallback; 400 if neither), POST `/{id}/deregister`.
- `AgentSseController` — GET `/{id}/events` (SSE connection).
- `AgentCommandController`POST `/{agentId}/commands`, POST `/groups/{group}/commands`, POST `/commands` (broadcast), POST `/{agentId}/commands/{commandId}/ack`, POST `/{agentId}/replay`.
- `AgentConfigController` — GET `/api/v1/agents/config`. Agent-authoritative config read: resolves (app, env) from JWT subject → registry (registry miss falls back to JWT env claim; no registry entry → 404 since application can't be derived).
### Ingestion (agent-only, JWT-authoritative)
- `LogIngestionController`POST `/api/v1/data/logs` (accepts `List<LogEntry>`; WARNs on missing identity, unregistered agents, empty payloads, buffer-full drops).
- `EventIngestionController`POST `/api/v1/data/events`.
- `ChunkIngestionController` — POST `/api/v1/ingestion/chunk/{executions|metrics|diagrams}`.
- `ExecutionController`POST `/api/v1/data/executions` (legacy ingestion path when ClickHouse disabled).
- `MetricsController`POST `/api/v1/data/metrics`.
- `DiagramController`POST `/api/v1/data/diagrams` (resolves applicationId + environment from the agent registry keyed on JWT subject; stamps both on the stored `TaggedDiagram`).
### Cross-env discovery (flat)
- `CatalogController` — GET `/api/v1/catalog` (merges managed apps + in-memory agents + CH stats; optional `?environment=` filter). DELETE `/api/v1/catalog/{applicationId}` (ADMIN: dismiss app, purge all CH data + PG record).
### Admin (cross-env, flat)
- `UserAdminController` — CRUD `/api/v1/admin/users`, POST `/{id}/roles`, POST `/{id}/set-password`.
- `RoleAdminController` — CRUD `/api/v1/admin/roles`.
- `GroupAdminController` — CRUD `/api/v1/admin/groups`.
- `OidcConfigAdminController` — GET/POST `/api/v1/admin/oidc`, POST `/test`.
- `SensitiveKeysAdminController` — GET/PUT `/api/v1/admin/sensitive-keys`. GET returns 200 or 204 if not configured. PUT accepts `{ keys: [...] }` with optional `?pushToAgents=true`. Fan-out iterates every distinct `(application, environment)` slice — intentional global baseline + per-env overrides.
- `ClaimMappingAdminController` — CRUD `/api/v1/admin/claim-mappings`, POST `/test`.
- `LicenseAdminController` — GET/POST `/api/v1/admin/license`.
- `ThresholdAdminController` — CRUD `/api/v1/admin/thresholds`.
- `AuditLogController` — GET `/api/v1/admin/audit`.
- `RbacStatsController` — GET `/api/v1/admin/rbac/stats`.
- `UsageAnalyticsController` — GET `/api/v1/admin/usage` (ClickHouse `usage_events`).
- `ClickHouseAdminController` — GET `/api/v1/admin/clickhouse/**` (conditional on `infrastructureendpoints` flag).
- `DatabaseAdminController` — GET `/api/v1/admin/database/**` (conditional on `infrastructureendpoints` flag).
### Other (flat)
- `DetailController` — GET `/api/v1/executions/{executionId}` + processor snapshot endpoints.
- `MetricsController` — exposes `/api/v1/metrics` and `/api/v1/prometheus` (server-side Prometheus scrape endpoint).
## runtime/ — Docker orchestration